Notes on operating range of Radioeye® wireless cameras

This tutorial explains several details about the wireless transmission of analogue video signals.

Analogue and digital transmission

In all classic CCTV systems each camera is connected to the monitor or video-recorder by cables. If the site does not permit running the cables the only solution is making a wireless bridge installing a transmitter closed to the camera and a receiver near the monitor/DVR.
Todays there are 2 kinds of Audio/Video transmitters on the market: analogue and digital.  
Analogue video transmitters have been very popular for several years. They transform the analogue video signal of the camera in a RF modulation.
Digital video transmitters are the state-of-the-art technology in video transmission. In this transmitters the analogue video signal is first converted in a digital stream before being transmitted. The receiver re-decodes the digital stream in an analogue video so that any TV set, DVR or monitor can be connected. Compared with analogue transmitters, these digital equipment provide much better RF immunity and 100% noise-free video.

Difference between digital transmission of analogue video and Wi-Fi

First of all it must be clear that digital transmitters for analogue video, like RE-DTX, have nothing to do with Wi-Fi.
Wi-Fi is used by IP cameras that generate a digital video to be played and managed by computers. On the contrary, in the digital transmitters of analogue video the digital stream exists only between transmitter and receiver, while the input from the camera and the output to the monitor are pure analogue composite video that can be connected to any video equipment like TV sets, video-recorders, video cameras etc.

Advantages of digital transmission

The recent development of digital transmission dramatically changed the market of wireless CCTV systems as well as it modified the world of broadcasting TV.  
The great advantage of digital RF transmission is that only 1-0 data are transferred instead of "From..To" values as in the analogue transmitters. For this reason the digital transmitters provide a clear noise-free video or nothing at all in case their operating range is exceeded. The "almost clear, so and so ..." area, typical of analogue transmission is not existing.
Besides this fundamental difference, the digital video is managed by a microprocessor, so several important features can be added for example in  order to improve RF interference immunity or to avoid unauthorized reception of the transmission.

Line of sight range and indoor range

Line of sight range
This is the maximum distance between a camera and receiver when there are no obstacles between the two, ensuring that the radio waves can travel freely through the air. The line-of-sight range can be measured fairly accurately using the appropriate methods. It should however be considered an approximate figure, as it can vary according to environmental conditions and external interference.
Indoor range
This is the maximum distance between a camera and receiver when there are various kinds of obstacles in between, such as walls or furnishings. The indoor range obviously depends on the number and type of obstacles present, as well as reflections off walls, and is therefore difficult to measure accurately.

Transmission in line of sight

The range of all DSE audio/video transmitter is always guaranteed in a line-of-sight condition (no obstacles between the antennas).
When designing your system, you should attempt to ensure maximum line of sight, to guarantee the best transmission range. However obstacles do exist and it is necessary to find a way round them. Every obstacle inevitably means a certain loss of signal, which is why it is important to ensure there are not too many, which would lead to a complete loss of signal.
Below are a few indications on how to deal with obstacles.

Obstacles to wireless transmission

What type of obstacles can influence transmission?
TThe obstacles which can influence wireless transmission from a Radioeye® camera are those located on the imaginary line between the receiver antenna and the camera antenna. Any other obstacle in the vicinity, or above or below, will have little influence. This is why the position of the camera is very important, as moving it by one meter can sometimes be enough to get around obstacles.
Metallic obstacles
Metal is the only substance commonly present in everyday applications which is capable of completely screening a wireless signal. If you were to shut a camera inside a sealed metal container, no signal at all would get through, even with the receiver right alongside. Fortunately it is rare to come across obstacles entirely composed of metal, but it is important to look out for large metal gates or metal shelves. It is also important to remember not to install the camera inside a metallic “cage” such as a lorry or closed cab, unless you are able to position the antenna on the outside, as described below.
Non-metallic obstacles
Non-metallic obstacles do not entirely screen wireless signals, meaning that the signal from a RadioEye camera will pass through. Each obstacle encountered does however introduce a certain level of signal attenuation. Thicker, denser obstacles, such as thick cement walls or roofing slabs weaken the signal more than less dense, thinner materials like wood, plastic etc.
The importance of the location of obstacles
There is a general rule here: the nearer the obstacles are to the transmitter (the camera), the weaker the signal will be. It is therefore a good idea to avoid positioning a camera immediately behind a wall (with respect to the receiver), because the signal would be weakened at the outset. The camera should be positioned in the most open location possible, pointing towards the receiver and ensuring there are no large obstacles near the transmitter, where the radio wave is narrower and it is more difficult to get round obstacles.

 

SLIGHT OBSTACLES WITHOUT CONSIDERABLE INFLUENCE ON SIGNAL RANGE

LARGE OBSTACLES WHICH AFFECT SIGNAL RANGE

Thin partition walls External or very thick walls
Plasterboard partitions – Office dividers Reinforced concrete pillars – Roofing slabs
Obstacles in plastic, wood or paper Metal obstacles – metal doors – sheet metal gates
Obstacles located very close to the receiver Obstacles located very close to the camera
Industrial warehouses – buildings with large empty spaces inside Residential buildings – buildings with dense, complex internal structures

Maximum operating distance between camera and receiver

For each wireless equipment DSE declares an open air, line-of-sight, maximum operating range which can be achieved without obstacles and in optimal environmental condition. This figure can be measured quite accurately,  but can anyway vary considerably according to the environment. In the event the presence of obstacles cannot be avoided please consider the following range reduction:

LINE-OF-SIGHT RANGE
No obstacles between antennas
RANGE WITH SLIGHT OBSTACLES
Small number of thin walls between antennas
RANGE WITH CONSIDERABLE OBSTACLES
Considerable number, or thick walls between antennas
Declared by manufacturer -30% -70%
 

Increasing range with directional antennas

RadioEye® cameras and transmitters come with omnidirectional antennas which transmit in all directions. However these can be replaced with a directional antenna which transmits in one precise direction. Directional antennas are usually connected to cameras and pointed in the direction of the receiver. Usually they are installed outdoor and connected to the camera by means of a cable (RE-CA4/5/6).
Using a directional antenna increase considerably the open air range, even over 50%.
The indoor range, is also improved but the benefit is reduced according to the number of obstacles.

Increasing range by avoiding critical obstacles

As a general rule, cameras should not be located close to obstacles as this would affect the outbound signal at the outset, preventing good signal propagation. However at times it is impossible to locate the camera in another area, due to the filming angle required. In this case it might be possible to leave the camera where it is and position the antenna elsewhere, in order to avoid the obstacle. We offer specific 1 to 5 m antenna cables for this purpose, but it should be noted that using these cables introduces a considerable degree of signal attenuation, in proportion to the length of the cable. The cable used should therefore be as short as possible.
Another option is to use a hard-wired camera connected to a separate transmitter (RE-DTX1)
with an Audio/Video cable. This option is preferable, as unlike the antenna cable, the audio/video cable can run for a several meters, without significant attenuation.

How to position cameras in order to optimize signal range

The optimum position for cameras, ensuring best performance, is in a circular pattern around the receiver, if possible with cameras equidistant from the receiver. In this way you can exploit the maximum range of the system (e.g. 150 m in one direction and 150 m in another), and the cameras, being offset, ensure the best possible transmission quality.
Obviously this layout is not always possible, as the site in question may not be suitable, or the reception point may not be central. The RadioEye® system enables you to locate the cameras where you wish, but where possible the following two set-ups should be avoided
 

Do not locate two cameras in line
You should avoid positioning two cameras along the same line, namely one behind the other, both pointing towards the receiver. The camera in front could interfere with the weaker signal coming from the further camera.

Do not position one camera close to the receiver and others much further away
A camera positioned 2-3 meters from the receiver could disturb the weaker signal from the more distant cameras.

If you are unsure about the most suitable solution for the range you require, send us an e-mail describing the position of the cameras and the receiver, indicating the distance between them and the obstacles present. We will be able to recommend the most suitable solution.